I read an article in the Star newspaper today. The headline read: “Arizona Indians fight ski resort plan.” Apparently, a ski resort located near Flagstaff, Arizona (Snowbowl) wants to expand their operations to compensate for the fact that they no longer get enough annual snowfall to keep the operation profitable. So they want to create a new ski slope and use 100% “reclaimed water” to make the necessary snow. “Reclaimed water” is made from processed sewerage. The Indians are upset because they say putting the reclaimed water-based snow on the mountain is, and I quote, “like putting a contaminated needle in your body containing poison.”
I take exception to the argument of the Indians – and on several levels. And no, I won’t play the ‘casino card,’ and talk about how it’s okay to build casinos that are wholly against the religious beliefs of many – as well as carrying certain significant cultural negatives with them. I’d like to look at some other, perhaps less obvious issues.
The case is being heard at the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. During the hearing, many Indians were present inside and outside of the courtroom – carrying signs and protesting the ski resort request. I must assume that the Indians did not walk to the courthouse, and therefore they stole crude oil from a helpless Mother Earth, and polluted the sacred air we all breathe with the fumes from the vehicles which took them there. The signs were made on paper products – which cuts down the sacred trees, and the mills which process the murdered trees into protest-sign-making-materials further destroy the sacred air we breathe.
And what about that water? Do no other animals deposit their waste products on that mountain? And the processed water fulfills the needs and desires of all plant life, and I am confident it’s not toxic for animal life, either. The earth has been a giant water filter for eons, what’s different now? I don’t know how to tell the Indians this, but sewerage has traits identical to plain old water. For example, it evaporates into the atmosphere and falls all over the planet – a LOT of it. No doubt, sewerage is falling on Jerusalem, Mecca, the Vatican, and all other religious icons and special places.
That’s enough. I just don’t get it. Especially when one drives through an Indian reservation and witnesses the despicable conditions the tribal governments allow their people to live in. Perhaps instead of paying lawyers, and financing trips to court, those monies could be better spent feeding and clothing and educating their people. But the Indians hardly have a monopoly on poorly ordered priorities.